Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations cowski on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

One line diagrams representation

Status
Not open for further replies.

lume7006

Electrical
Oct 2, 2007
103
Dear colleagues,

This may be a very fool question, however, I would like to receive some feedeback related to the standarized way to express in a single line diagram the following:
Size of conductors
Number of conductors

Typically, we receive many one line diagramas showing data in a non standarized format, let's say:
12-500 kCM
When we ask to the person who did it, the answer is 4 conductors per phase, however, sometimes, we have seen that the feeder ampacity only "matches" with 12 conductors per phase.

I guess there should be a standar way to express this and avoid confusions, because of that I hope that from your experience may recommended me something to look for and avoid mistakes.

Best Regards,
 
Replies continue below

Recommended for you

There are customs, but no standards, at least in the US.

To reduce ambiguity and opportunity for contractor creativity, we generally would write:

4-500 kcmil/phase

or

4-4"C with [3-500 kcmil, 1-#4/0G] each

This is also covered in our legend.

In your part of the universe, the custom may be totally different.
 
Hi dpc,

I thank your reply!

As you mentioned, sometimes, our customer has enough creativity, some other, even the customer does not have a clear idea of the meaning because has had so many contractors and each one defined its own style but there´s nothing written.

We typically follow our national code which is almost a translation of NEC, however, as you stated, there is no code!

Best Regards
 
The contractor's creativity generally runs toward finding new reasons why a change order is required. :cool:

Probably putting an example in the legend is the best approach.
 
I would normally write ... 4 sets each: 3#500, 1#4/0G - 4". Pretty obvious to me and never been questioned. And no I don't write MCM or kcmil for that matter. Still think kcmil sounds like the name of a country singer.
 
I would normally write ... 4 sets each: 3#500, 1#4/0G - 4". Pretty obvious to me and never been questioned. And no I don't write MCM or kcmil for that matter. Still think kcmil sounds like the name of a country singer.
But #500 is meaningless.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor