robinxie
Chemical
- Nov 13, 2001
- 52
Hello, everyone,
This question comes in my mind today suddenly.
According to B31.3, if SE<SA, the piping system could pass the displacement stress analysis.
SA=f(1.25Sc+0.25Sh) or SA=f(1.25(Sc+Sh)-SL)
Either of those two equations depends on Factor f, or say, Cycles N.
Let's assume there are two exactly same piping systems (same geometry, same pressure, same temperature). The cycles of ths first one is 7000, f=1.0. It could pass the stress analysis. The cycles of the other is 150000, f=0.5, so the SA is only half of the first one, and it may not pass stress analysis.
But when I use programs for stress analysis (CAESAR II, or something else), I just input geometry, pressure, temperature, etc. I never specified N or f.
What's the problem here?
Thanks ahead.
This question comes in my mind today suddenly.
According to B31.3, if SE<SA, the piping system could pass the displacement stress analysis.
SA=f(1.25Sc+0.25Sh) or SA=f(1.25(Sc+Sh)-SL)
Either of those two equations depends on Factor f, or say, Cycles N.
Let's assume there are two exactly same piping systems (same geometry, same pressure, same temperature). The cycles of ths first one is 7000, f=1.0. It could pass the stress analysis. The cycles of the other is 150000, f=0.5, so the SA is only half of the first one, and it may not pass stress analysis.
But when I use programs for stress analysis (CAESAR II, or something else), I just input geometry, pressure, temperature, etc. I never specified N or f.
What's the problem here?
Thanks ahead.