Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations cowski on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Recent content by WHEngineer

  1. WHEngineer

    How is a hand probe test evaluated?

    I agree with msucog about geotechs without probe rods. However,my wife can't understand why I leave my probe rod in the truck when we drive on vacation - I feel naked without it!
  2. WHEngineer

    How is a hand probe test evaluated?

    Like most tools, it depends on how you use it. We typically use a probe rod for footing inspections to give an idea of general soil conditions in the footing. Then, we follow up with dynamic cone penetrometer testing in any questionable areas as well as at least one test in critical or firm...
  3. WHEngineer

    Field Density Test Results Don't Match Observed Soil Behavior

    This may seem like a silly question, but you would not believe how many times I've seen this problem. How long are you letting each proctor point set to equalize moisture content? With gravelly clay soils, I've seen it take several days to obtain a uniform moisture content. We actually just...
  4. WHEngineer

    Why do engineers encourage people to become engineers

    Wow! Who'd a thunk that my little ole Georgia Tech degree would top the pack with a 14.2% ROI.
  5. WHEngineer

    Why do people give up engineering?

    Why do people give up engineering? Back in the recent boom years, it was hard watching developers put a contract on a piece of land, hire a civil for a small percentage to do the layout for the development and then sell the development for a huge sum. The engineers typically did most of the...
  6. WHEngineer

    Young engineer confused about career track

    To reiterate brandoncdg's point, the fieldwork is very important. When I started 25+ years ago, a rookie engineer could expect to spend his first two years performing essentially field tech work. The next two years integrated the engineer into more relevant design work while still having a...
  7. WHEngineer

    Head Hunter vs. Direct Hire

    I have been hired once and received offers several times by using a recruiter. Unless the company hires only through a recruiter, then it is often best to go it on your own. On my last job hunt (two years ago), I had four offers. Two of the offers were on my own and two were through...
  8. WHEngineer

    Are engineers personally liable for a mistake when working for a comp

    In my area of the Southeast US, if a lawyer is suing a company, there is no extra cost or effort to add the PE to the lawsuit. The PE is often added not to actually collect any money, but to provide the threat that they may actually go after your personal assets. This is often done in hopes of...
  9. WHEngineer

    Why do engineers encourage people to become engineers

    After twenty-five years of practice, I love engineering as much now as when I started. I would gladly recommend the field to anyone who truly has a love for problem solving. I am in a field where on rainy days I can sit in the office and prepare reports and on sunny days I can schedule trips...
  10. WHEngineer

    Does liability transfer beyond contracts?

    You can exclude third party reliance in the limitations sections of your reports (as per our lawyer). That way, by accepting the report, the third party also acknowledges and accepts the limitations. This is very common in Phase I Environmental Site Assessments where the property owner has the...
  11. WHEngineer

    Does liability transfer beyond contracts?

    This is definitely a question for the lawyers. If your contract specifically excludes third-party liability, or you have an adequate hold-harmless clause, you may be safe. However, I have found that residential homeowners tend to be emotional about these issues and rational cost analysis does...
  12. WHEngineer

    Errors/Omissions Insurance questions

    idecharlotte - I once thought that way, until I was sued over a $2500 job. I had performed the work in accordance with the clients wishes and the client dictated all of the parameters of the work. My contract was solid and my lawyer told me the client had no case. I just did not tell him what...
  13. WHEngineer

    embedment depth of pier design - 2007CBC/IBC2006

    To add to my previous post, a small diameter pier or pile, especially of wood, will not provide significant bending resistance at depths over 12 feet, likely resulting in unacceptable lateral deflections.
  14. WHEngineer

    embedment depth of pier design - 2007CBC/IBC2006

    The code does not restrict the maximum embedment depth to 12 feet for the non-constrained case, only the lateral load calcs are limited to 12 feet. For an axial loaded pier, the depths can be greater. In addition, effective lateral resistance will decrease with depth, so 12 feet is likely an...
  15. WHEngineer

    Errors/Omissions Insurance questions

    I was generally able to find e&o insurance through the same agent that provided my general liability and workman's comp insurance. I had policies through CNA and DPIC that were reasonable (for a geotech) that cost in the range of 3% of total revenues. For protection of earlier work, I was also...

Part and Inventory Search