Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations cowski on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Recent content by vincentpa

  1. vincentpa

    Beam Bearing Stiffeners for 2010 AISC Section J10

    Plus, AISC specifically tells the engineer to what forces to design the well to the flanges and the webs. Neither of those forces address bending.
  2. vincentpa

    Beam Bearing Stiffeners for 2010 AISC Section J10

    Yes I did. Thanks. But, what I don't necessarily agree with is designing the plate to resist bending without considering the contribution of the flange. The plate and the flange will act like a T section. I found an example somewhat similar to this in Blodgett on page 3.3-25 and 3.3-26. The...
  3. vincentpa

    Beam Bearing Stiffeners for 2010 AISC Section J10

    Does anyone have a design methodology or can anyone point me to a design guide for the design of partial-depth web and flange stiffeners according to the 2010 Edition of the AISC Steel Code section J10? I cannot find any guidance on how to design these elements anywhere. The description of the...
  4. vincentpa

    Joints in elevated concrete slab on form deck

    If you don't use control joints, for a slab on form deck, would you use ACI minimum temperature and shrinkage (T&S) steel requiremente (rho=0.0018) for reinforcement perpendicular to the main flexural reinforcement? Or would you place welded wire fabric (WWF)? Our slab is total 8" thick with...
  5. vincentpa

    Joints in elevated concrete slab on form deck

    We have an elevated concrete slab on form deck in a large industrial building. How often do you space the control joints? How often do you space the expansion joints? Where do you locate the control and expansion joints? I imagine that the location of the joints will differ with the orientation...
  6. vincentpa

    Seismic force for Mechanical Equipment

    We have a large piece of mechanical equipment that is self supporting and weighs approximately 300k. The manufacturer did not supply seismic loads. We did the superstructure design but not the foundation design. We need to supply the foundation engineers with the seismic loads. Which chapter in...
  7. vincentpa

    3 Sided Diaphragm Design Guide

    Call Vulcraft and they will send you a derivation and a design example. I don't have mine here at the office or I would scan it for you. They will also help you with the calculation.
  8. vincentpa

    Wind Load on a Circular Storage Bin

    I am designing the support structure for a circular storage bin that is 54 ft. in diameter and 100 feet tall. Which provision in ASCE 7-05 should be used to calculate the wind load on the bin: Section 6.5.12.2.1 Rigid Buildings of All Heights (using Kd=0.95); or 6.5.15 Design of Wind Loads on...
  9. vincentpa

    Question for the Oldtimers??

    Wrought iron is made by flattening of a piece of iron and folding it over and repeating the process to remove the slag. It wasn't very efficient. In Newman's book "Structural Renovation of Buildings," he states welding to wrought iron is prblematic and he references "Field Welding to Existing...
  10. vincentpa

    ASCE 7-05 Sec 6.2 Wind Loads :Enclosure classification

    ASCE 7 is tying to confuse you. They make the definitions of partially enclosed and open so you can calculate them. They give three categories. If your structure is not partially enclosed or open by calculation (not by what you see), then it is enclosed. The structure is considered enclosed even...
  11. vincentpa

    ASD vs. LRFD, Who Decides?

    Green book for green engineers. Black book for the souls of most professors.
  12. vincentpa

    ASD vs. LRFD, Who Decides?

    271828, read my post, two posts up; the post before the last post. does that even make sense?
  13. vincentpa

    ASD vs. LRFD, Who Decides?

    271828, I agree with you that both LRFD and ASD shouldn't be taught. It would take too much time and other topics would not be covered. It would only serve to confuse the students. It would be like teaching Spanish and Italian in the same class and then ask the students to have a conversation...
  14. vincentpa

    ASD vs. LRFD, Who Decides?

    JAE, I didn't call you a fool. I called the act of removing ASD from the Steel Design Manual foolish. Please read my post more carefully. 271828, Please change your name to something catchy!!! I can't remember all of the numbers. I have crawled out from under tree or out of the gutter depending...
  15. vincentpa

    ASD vs. LRFD, Who Decides?

    Bliman, Right on! Not only have most professors never designed, they've never been to a jobsite. Even with inspectors there, the structure will not be built as designed. Put fat into it! Going onto a jobsite will put the fear of God in you.

Part and Inventory Search