Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations cowski on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Recent content by structuralengr89

  1. structuralengr89

    Framing a New Roof on Top of an Existing PEMB Roof

    Would anyone ever consider framing a new roof on top of an existing PEMB? I have someone who has adjacent pre-engineered metal buildings and wants to frame a new roof between them to get rid of the valley. Reasons to not do it: 1. Expansion/Contraction. Tying 2 buildings together with framing...
  2. structuralengr89

    Structural Cost Increases for federal "Build America Buy America Act"

    Does anyone have any info on the structural cost increases to projects conforming to the new federal "Build America Buy America Act"? Or any recent articles where this is addressed?
  3. structuralengr89

    Flood Design Below the BFE in Coastal A Zone

    For those of you familiar with coastal flood design, I have a small project where an Owner wants to build an attached garage to an existing home in Flood Zone AE. The existing home was built prior to the most recent FIRM and the FFE of the home is at 13' and the BFE is at 18'. The building...
  4. structuralengr89

    Can Drywall Studs be used in Tension?

    Can drywall studs which are non-structural/non-load bearing be used in tension. Specifically these studs: https://www.clarkdietrich.com/products/prostud-drywall-framing-system#description I have a project where a contractor has hung very large sections of wall from the roof deck. The work is...
  5. structuralengr89

    Hard Rock Hotel under construction in New Orleans collapses...

    Many good lessons for Engineers on this failure: 1. Designated Connection Design. Do you designate others to design the connections on your projects? Guess what, if it fails you will be sued. In fact, everyone on the project team gets sued - architect, contractor, structural, electrical...
  6. structuralengr89

    Hard Rock Hotel under construction in New Orleans collapses...

    Yeah, he's definitely standing bow-legged
  7. structuralengr89

    Hard Rock Hotel under construction in New Orleans collapses...

    I hope the guy in the yellow vest in the lower right hand corner is getting paid well to stand in that location.
  8. structuralengr89

    Hard Rock Hotel under construction in New Orleans collapses...

    Winelady, The deck is not spanning in the direction shown on the plans...its spanning in the other direction driving all the load to the perimeter W10x19...Try W10x19 spanning 25'-9" with 24' of trib.
  9. structuralengr89

    Hard Rock Hotel under construction in New Orleans collapses...

    So why didn't the separate application catch the problem (if, indeed, it is a problem) before importing or translating into REVIT? It not the job of the computer program to "CATCH THE PROBLEM". It is the job of the engineer to know what he is doing. How about some basic span to depth ratios...
  10. structuralengr89

    Hard Rock Hotel under construction in New Orleans collapses...

    REVIT is BIM modeling...It is typically not used in the US for structural analysis...it has replaced CAD for providing Construction Documents...I would guess that in Louisiana most designers would be using Bentley's Ram Structural System for analysis. During the initial stages of the design...
  11. structuralengr89

    Hard Rock Hotel under construction in New Orleans collapses...

    Oh my goodness...Even the guys out in the field know a W10x19 is a "Shit Beam"
  12. structuralengr89

    Hard Rock Hotel under construction in New Orleans collapses...

    I have heard the Hyatt Regency collapse in Ethics Seminars over the years so many times, that I literally cringe when I hear a speaker bring it up. Mark my words, this will be the new Hyatt Ethics Seminar. My hope is that somehow NCSEA and state MOs will use this to push state legislative...
  13. structuralengr89

    Hard Rock Hotel under construction in New Orleans collapses...

    Dold...You get a star for your W10x19 girder comment! Let's hope those plans you linked which are sealed and do not state NFC are not what was used for construction!!!

Part and Inventory Search