Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations cowski on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Recent content by StructDave

  1. StructDave

    pipe bridge support

    Thanks everyone. In a conference with the client I discovered the foundations are soil-based (not anchored to bedrock) and we are in a marine environment, which tells me the foundations will eventually creep (rotate) out of position. A permanent negative moment from the pipe bridge will...
  2. StructDave

    pipe bridge support

    Thanks racookpe1978; the intent is pipes will be supported on a bridge structure. The "Towers" will be braced frame structures no higher than the bridge. Pipes will have guided supports that allow their thermal movement to take place independently of the bridge. My dilemma is only about whether...
  3. StructDave

    Cold Formed Portal Shed with Tilt Panel Cladding

    I agree. Would they consider upgrading the girts to hot-rolled channels to address the securing of panels, including at least some period of time in a fire, and can you argue that the portal frames would collapse inward? Otherwise, better find another fire-rated assembly. We have used other...
  4. StructDave

    10-year old facade completely rotted on one side

    Almost reasonable. Are you in a cold climate? It seems more likely moisture would have condensed there when the roof-side was cold. Same result. If moisture were trapped in the space when the roof-side was hot, wouldn't it remain in vapour-form, at least until cooler evening hours?
  5. StructDave

    pipe bridge support

    Thanks JAE, pun appreciated. Also the observation; my client would have to devise a sliding guide with hold-down capability for the negative reaction. Forces are such that a Teflon-SS type bearing is warranted, but they'll have to invert half of them. Definitely something I will point out.
  6. StructDave

    pipe bridge support

    A client (large Eng. company) asked me to review a single-span pipe bridge design, span >100ft. In the initial review (3 weeks ago) we introduced the subject of bridge camber, and had extensive discussions about weight, erection, galvanizing etc. In the second round it became clear the design...
  7. StructDave

    Engineering regulatory landscape in Poland; collaboration?

    A Canadian client is bidding to supply a process vessel 20m tall, with platforms and accessory equipment. Foundations will be designed by others, and the process and mechanical needs are not our concern. 1. Can a design satisfying ASCE-7/IBC or NBC be imported and used, or is there a Polish or...
  8. StructDave

    Ripping TJIs to Stiffen a Floor?

    Thank you all for very helpful observations and comments! Concerns about gluing, the thin web, etc are well-founded. Use of steel was considered (we can get anything fabricated, but first would try a standard CFC or Z-Girt). Our code allows "existing construction" to remain, with load...
  9. StructDave

    Ripping TJIs to Stiffen a Floor?

    An attic has been built with finished rooms on a ceiling of 2x4s spanning 17ft. As expected, the ceiling sagged. The owner is into a fully gutted renovation of the storey below the attic (not modifying the attic itself). The attic kneewalls are built tight to the roof rafters. So I'm looking at...
  10. StructDave

    SolidWorks for steel structures?

    Thanks folks. This is really helpful feedback.
  11. StructDave

    Sealed drawings ownership

    Previous two posts give good reasons to retain. Here's another one. If sealed drawings are mis-used such as for another project, maybe by alteration to title block etc, the EOR that has kept files is better able to distance themself, recover damages etc. In the digital age, keeping files...
  12. StructDave

    SolidWorks for steel structures?

    (searched around and couldn't find any threads on this; also couldn't find a more suitable forum) Does anyone here use Solidworks to model steel structures? - Small simple ones, i.e. an access platform with stair, beams, posts, guardrail? - Mid-size, i.e. a small building addition or penthouse...
  13. StructDave

    Needs recommendation of flooring system for Truss pedestrian bridge???

    Precast sounds good here, since you don't have to tie it in. You'll want to consider the topping concrete for dead load, and let it fill the end spaces so the slabs are secured in place within the steel structure. To add one thing to the remarks about the trusses, consider how the erector will...
  14. StructDave

    How to Check if Concrete Spalling Reinforcement is needed

    There are other possible resons for the spalling... Rebar corrosion? You didn't mention any rust staining so let's assume that's not a factor. Concrete damaged by chemical attack, freeze-thaw exposure, or simply deficient in the first place? Did the load change at any time? Yes your bearing...
  15. StructDave

    Concrete and Sugar

    I have heard the bag of sugar story as concretemasonry said; my dad had one of the earliest ready-mix operations back in the forties and fifties. Breakdowns were more common. As of the late sixties and on, I don't remember seeing bags of sugar in any of the trucks.

Part and Inventory Search