Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations cowski on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Recent content by shirsch

  1. shirsch

    Large Stormwater Hydraulic Pump Manufacturers

    Yes, we can use axial flow pumps and the TDH is only 16.2 ft.
  2. shirsch

    Large Stormwater Hydraulic Pump Manufacturers

    I am looking for manufacturers of stormwater pumps capable of pumping at 67,500 gpm each (2 total). I have information from MWI and I need to contact other manufacturers. Does anyone know of another pump manufacturer who builds stormwater pumps this size?
  3. shirsch

    PE from project management.

    You will need to prove that your work experience is in engineering and you will need a PE to sign off for all of your years of experience. I am not sure if there is a PE at your new PM job, but if not you may not be eligible to sit for the PE exam. How do you like working in PM versus engineering?
  4. shirsch

    3-inch force main

    Use HDPE
  5. shirsch

    use of Treated sewage effluent for construction

    The WWTP where they get this treated effluent must have a land application NPDES permit to discharge onto soil and this permit has a specific site where the effluent must be discharged. I have never heard of a contractor wanting to use treated effluent for compaction and I have never heard of...
  6. shirsch

    WaterCAD and AutoCAD

    Some versions of AutoCAD are not comapatable with WaterCAD. Contact Haested to find out which version of AutoCAD is most compatable with your version of WaterCAD. You will be able to bring in pics/maps/etc into AutoCAD using AutoCAD Map. You can do all of your line work in there and tranfer...
  7. shirsch

    Sewer Force Mains On Top of One Another

    I would make an effort to coordinate the two force mains into one. The POTW will not accept two force mains on top of one another due to lack of access for normal operation and maintenance. Save your client some money and coordinate with the other pump station project. You may even be able to...
  8. shirsch

    Forcemain - Material and Cost

    It would be easiest to use 2" (I like SDR 11) HDPE pipe. It comes in a roll of probably at least 1000 ft (maybe more). You can install via horizontal directional drilling without even having to dig a trench. Very easy and the cost should be about the same or less as open trench for a 3000 ft...
  9. shirsch

    WaterCAD questions

    You can contact Bentley to get an "upgraded" version of WaterCAD to allow you to use more components in your model. I would be cautious trying to break the system into two 5000 component systems, unless you have a very definitive break point where the output from one model could be used as the...
  10. shirsch

    Directional Drilling Question

    I would also be worried about how the deformation will effect your connection to addtional fittings. I don't think the manufacturer makes joints or fittings for a 5" x 2" oblong pipe.
  11. shirsch

    Sewer Force Main Condition Assessment

    We don't have access to the inside of the force main like you would for a gravity sewer line, so the laser profiling is not really an option. Also, we need to keep the force main active during inspection.
  12. shirsch

    Sewer Force Main Condition Assessment

    fbs international doesn't think their guided wave technology will provide the results I am looking for on a DIP line. I am currently talking to a pipe inspection company, Acuren, that regularly serves the oil pipe industry. They have a digital radiography technology that they feel can provide...
  13. shirsch

    Sewer Force Main Condition Assessment

    alexcmmi, thanks for the helpful info. It sounds like you are in a flat coastal area. Are you in the SE? I have been looking at pricing for the ultrasonic pipe wall profiling. Do you have any cost information for this? How long ago did you use this technology? The failure was at a high...
  14. shirsch

    Engineers turned Brewmasters

    jorton, where do you work? That sounds like a good office to be in.
  15. shirsch

    Sewer Force Main Condition Assessment

    Internal corrosion from hydrogen sulfide is the cause. The cementitious liner was gone in 4 of 5 coupons. We sampled at high points on the line. I know why and how the line is corroding, but I need to find a technique for examining the degree of corrosion, i.e. a condition assessment. Your...

Part and Inventory Search