Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations cowski on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Recent content by qcjr

  1. qcjr

    Excentrically braced frames - How to limit link rotation

    Thanks for the reply :) It is indeed a difficult bracing type to design and balance. However, it is quite practical to actually allow for some windows and other architectural features :)
  2. qcjr

    Excentrically braced frames - How to limit link rotation

    Greetings, I am designing a 9-story building with excentrically braced frames in one direction, using the Canadian Building Code. According to the S16-01 standard (concerning steel design), the inelastic component of the link rotation is limited to 0.08 rad (for link with e < 1.6Mp/Vp). This...
  3. qcjr

    Distribution of Base Shear in a 9-story building

    Thanks for the answer. I also checked with the software developer, my assumption about including all the vibration modes in the results table was right.
  4. qcjr

    Distribution of Base Shear in a 9-story building

    I am using Advance Design America. I just spoke with a colleague, and he confirmed me these are the results from the entire response spectrum analysis, meaning those shear numbers are for all the vibration modes, and not only the principal mode. Is this right?
  5. qcjr

    Distribution of Base Shear in a 9-story building

    Greetings, I am doing the analysis of a 9-story building using a dynamic analysis. The building is a residential complex, built using steel. In one direction, concentrically-braced frames (limited ductility) are used and in the other direction, excentrically-braced frames. In the principal...
  6. qcjr

    Punching shear of a steel HSS column through flat slab

    Well, thanks all for the answers. The column isn't part of the LFRS: the slab is a diaphragm transferring the lateral loads to shear walls on the perimeter. The slab is supported with a thick plate with studs (so far). I believe the reinforcement of the column strip will be put on each sides...
  7. qcjr

    Punching shear of a steel HSS column through flat slab

    Hello guys, We are designing a concrete flat slab supported by steel HSS columns with plates. Basically, the contractor (who is also the client) wants to have continuous steel columns (not interrupted at each level). I have calculated the punching shear through the slab by checking the minimum...
  8. qcjr

    SAFE v12 punching shear

    alphaxy: I would love to actually help you do that but I am pretty young in my profession and never had to design a raft yet (at leats, not an entire one, only a portion of an existing raft, by hand).
  9. qcjr

    SAFE v12 punching shear

    Unfortunately, I almost never used ETABS so far. I am still looking to find a project where I will use it. Sorry about that.
  10. qcjr

    SAFE v12 punching shear

    alphaxy, Yes, that's what I decided in the end. I still hope CSI will actually update SAFE v12 and fix some bugs. I found that, as you thought, the punching area isn't always accurate. Sometimes, for some unknown reasons, SAFE would "ignore" the added thickness from a drop panel.
  11. qcjr

    SAFE v12 punching shear

    Thank you. I found the paper on the Computers and Structures website, but it did not solve my problem.
  12. qcjr

    SAFE v12 punching shear

    Hello guys, I have a model of a flat plate, with a couple of shear walls on the perimeter. I have trying to verify the punching shear of the columns but for some reason I don't know, SAFE won't calculate the punching shear on the perimeter columns ("N/C" result). When does SAFE stop...
  13. qcjr

    Foundation subgrade modulus

    Ok, thanks for the input, guys. We just bought the Canadian Foundation Engineering Manual, which gives some estimated values for the subgrade reaction modulus.
  14. qcjr

    Cracks in Flat Plate Slab

    I may be wrong but it looks like punching shear cracking. As to why this happens on the roof only (and not the other floor), maybe the exposed slab has suffered significant temperature shrinkage..? I would gladly provide more information but haven't seen this a lot.
  15. qcjr

    CAN/CSA-S16-01 14.3.4

    Forgot to add "...since this is about "compensation" of the thin web by a thick flange to avoid stability problems."

Part and Inventory Search