Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations cowski on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Recent content by MickMc

  1. MickMc

    A333 Gr 6 Minimum Temperature

    Worked on a project recent years where we considered using stress ratio but combined stresses clause thought to be impractical so created LTCS pipe class for affected lines with impact testing at -50 DegC.
  2. MickMc

    Selection of branch fitting, sweepolet or Reducing Tee

    Reducing Tee is usually preferred in branch tables 1-2 sizes down but guessing selection of sweepolet is due to vibration concerns although I would have thought that would be in lieu of weldolet type not reducing tee.
  3. MickMc

    Can API 6D valves have API trim 5? (Is this relatively uncommon?)

    API 600 I believe has just standardised typical trims with typical services therefore you can quote API Trim 5 outwith API 600 Valves in your case API 6D.
  4. MickMc

    Career Advice - Piping Materials Engineer

    In my experience in mostly Oil & Gas if you join as piping materials engineer that will be area you are working as piping has 3 general areas within disciple which are layout, stress and materials the latter 2 being considered the specialised within piping. You will be responsible for...
  5. MickMc

    Minimum Temperature Pipe Class Boundary

    Seems strange one to me as for there is no change in allowable pressure under 38°C (41.4 barg 316L) and fig 323.3.2b not relevant for SS in my view as impact testing not required. It may be that your piping specs require additional measures e.g. valve testing, packing at temperatures lower than...
  6. MickMc

    Min Design Of API 5L GR.B

    LI is correct in his interpretation and the notes accompanying table important, be careful if you are defining your piping class minimum temp (API 5L GrB) as -29°C as it is related to wall thickness. I would steer away from Stress Ratio except for short term conditions where you will have to...
  7. MickMc

    GRE/HDPE Piping Stress Analysis

    I am not a stress engineer but can tell you in Middle East Projects which I have been working on in Client side in recent years use of non metallic piping for water systems including FW is common. Most of my experience is with GRE but current project is HDPE which is underground only due to...
  8. MickMc

    Any Difference between SS316L and dual certified SS316/SS316L?

    As pointed out by XL83NL it is more common to spec 316/316L and 304/304L and get the increased strength of former and weldability of latter. Dual certified are readily available from suppliers more probably than single spec as can be seen from your vendor offer.
  9. MickMc

    welded vs flanged

    In general minimise flange joints as they are considered potential leak path therefore use when connecting to equipment, valves or instrumentation and as mentioned for certain services such as lethal/toxic all connections may be welded type. For hydrocarbon service you may also be required to...
  10. MickMc

    Am asking for the common practice r

    In my experience in piping we ask for equipment supplier to provide counter flanges for their nozzles where they are outwith ASME B16.5/16.47 scope with us providing wall thickness of connecting pipe.
  11. MickMc

    PSV Discharge Piping

    Guys, Thanks for response. In the case in attachment it is 4x6 PSV and isolation in this case is gate valve and all valves are mandated full bore at PSV and API 520 guidelines are being met regarding flange sizes etc. This is just one instance in this process plant area with all PSV taking...
  12. MickMc

    PSV Discharge Piping

    Our Contractor on this FEED stage of project has taken this approach to configuration of PSV discharge piping going to closed system in this case to flare with the purpose being to save money on isolation valve side. (see attachment) I have not seen this approach before and we have concerns...
  13. MickMc

    Reciprocating compressor package pipe schedule

    You do not mention pipe diameters as it is common to have a minimum schedule for small bore piping for mechanical strength e.g.operators standing on skid piping.
  14. MickMc

    Piping Stress Analysis Software

    I don't personally use Stress packages so I cannot comment on pro & cons but after 15 years of working on client side in Middle East Oil & Gas Projects I can tell you that the client will dictate which software is to be used in Scope of Work based on its preference and regarding stress I have...
  15. MickMc

    Handwheel height above grade

    See uploaded file which IMHO gives a reasonable approach to acceptable handwheel heights but actual may vary between clients and their operation preferences. Note that 71 inch seems to me to be on the high side except for small bore valves, think of the torque required. I would also add that it...

Part and Inventory Search