Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations cowski on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Recent content by MickE

  1. MickE

    hide formulas

    From the menu bar, go <Format <Cells select the Protection Tab, check both boxes I'd suggest. OK Then back to the menu bar, go <Tools <Protection <Protect Sheet.
  2. MickE

    Need times for "hand finishing" stainless

    I am developing a spreadsheet for cost estimating custom built, stainless steel tanks. Can anyone help with average times per unit area (or point me in the right direction) for finishing to 0.3Ra microns (240 grit) and to 0.1Ra (320 grit) from say No.1 Mill Finish 304 or 316 plate. A typical...
  3. MickE

    Seeking a simple formula to find deflection of flat ends on tanks

    Many thanks for doing that butelja, those answers restore my confidence in Mr Roark :) Looks like I'm going to have to track down a copy that I can borrow...certainly can't afford to buy one.
  4. MickE

    Welding stainless steel to steel

    For tanks, we normaly weld the carbon steel to a stainless &quot;backing&quot; plate, the same material as the tank and welded to it. This is quite common practice for welding mild steel legs to stainless tanks. There should also be a small &quot;weep&quot; hole in the backing plate.
  5. MickE

    Seeking a simple formula to find deflection of flat ends on tanks

    butelja Many thanks for your assistance, it is truly appreciated. Perhaps you could help me with one more question? In the Machinery's Handbook formula, I presume that d is the deflection, correct? The units of the formula are mass x length^2/E x length^3 If d is deflection, should I presume it...
  6. MickE

    Seeking a simple formula to find deflection of flat ends on tanks

    Thank you for that butelja. You've helped me get my thinking sorted out. When calculating deflection using the Roark formulae, I kept getting results that were clearly wrong...overstated. Like the deflection of a 2.0mm bottom on a 1000 litre, 1200mm diam tank is more than 5 mtrs. That simply...
  7. MickE

    Seeking a simple formula to find deflection of flat ends on tanks

    Thanks to both of you for taking the time to respond. They are metal tanks MJCronin, with suspended bottoms, ie on legs or skirt. I have Roark and found the approach overwhelming in its complexity. As you have both pointed out, a flat bottom on any support is almost theoreticaly not feasible but...
  8. MickE

    Seeking a simple formula to find deflection of flat ends on tanks

    Does anyone know a simple way to determine the deflection of flat suspended tank bottoms? Or if the maximum deflection was set to a percentage of the diameter, say by visual acceptability, how should I go about finding the required thickness? For simplicity and if it is a part of the solution...
  9. MickE

    From Excel data to 3D drawing anyone??

    Can anyone point me in a direction? I am trying to locate a mid to low end drawing program for generating rendered sketches of tanks from Excel data. Does such an interface exist? I think &quot;mid to low end&quot; because I don't need all the power to do everything else that the...

Part and Inventory Search