Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations cowski on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Recent content by GNight

  1. GNight

    Stamp Removal

    I quit a job and discovered the company had my stamp on revisions I'd never seen (through contacts at plan check and the local copy house). Took an ugly wrangle to get my name off. Seems to me that unless the job is built the EOR can still be easily replaced and it's not fair to ask the old...
  2. GNight

    3x Required at Shear Wall Panel Joints?

    Similar provision in UBC is based on the capacity of the wall, not design value, so the controlling load case is irrelevant. Interesting if the IBC interpretation is different.
  3. GNight

    Employees stamping drawings

    You're liable for everything you stamp long after you quit your job. You just hope the lawyers go after the insurance company and deep pockets, not your pineapple stand in Maui.
  4. GNight

    Employees stamping drawings

    One way of looking at it is "If you did the work, you stamp it". Clear about that. The other way, the thing I'm trying to bring up here is: If you picked the job, stand to make the profit, wrote the contract, decided on the insurance policy to cover errors, why can't you take responsiblity for...
  5. GNight

    Employees stamping drawings

    I've worked for engineering firms and for contractors and this is not a hypothetical question. Been asked more than once by other engineers if I thought they should take that "promotion" into stamping, a tough one because it means more money. Even quit over being bullied into stamping...
  6. GNight

    Employees stamping drawings

    Talking about licensed engineers who stamp their own stuff, but aren't owners or partners. Like I said, I know it's common. In engineering, there's always interpretation, not as much a right and a wrong way but about five different ways you can look at the problem. Say you're conservative...
  7. GNight

    Employees stamping drawings

    I know it's common enough, but what do you all think of employees stamping/sealing drawings? It bothers me, especially in construcion companies where cutting corners puts money directly in the owner's pocket. You got to do what's right if you're the EOR, but you got follow orders if you want...
  8. GNight

    Distributed Load vs. Point Load

    If it's early in the design of the building, he might have used a conservative shortcut to leave room for error and revision down the line.
  9. GNight

    Aluminum Mullion Reinforcing!

    If you can, make the steel section strong enough to take all the load.

Part and Inventory Search