Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations cowski on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Recent content by FinnB

  1. FinnB

    Sheet Piled Shaft Below Water With Pipe Penetration

    I am working on a project were we have to make a new connection to a pipe 16.5 feet below ground level. The pipe is beside a river with the underlying ground consisting of a free draining gravel. The plan is to sink a shaft 15ft by 15 ft on plan using sheet piles and excavate down to the pipe...
  2. FinnB

    Is It Still Acceptable To Use British Standards BS8110 and BS5950

    Can anybody tell me if it is still acceptable to use British Standards that have been withdrawn and been superseded by Euro Codes. Does anybody know for example the transition period from from BS8110 to EC2 for concrete? Must EC2 be used not for all new concrete structures?
  3. FinnB

    Swelling Forces of Timber Surrounded By Concrete

    I am working on a project using a secant pile wall as a temporary support to allow the construction of an underground tank built below the water table. The contractor has left some timber formwork trapped between the secant pile wall and the finished poured concrete wall. I have some concern...
  4. FinnB

    Bow String Roof Truss - Wind Uplift Net Negative Pressure

    dhengr.......thanks for your comment. The concept of tensioning the arch member is interesting. The attachment you can't open is of a very standard lattice truss design that I put forward to the architect. In terms of there being a "secret" there is none. I am also not really looking for...
  5. FinnB

    Bow String Roof Truss - Wind Uplift Net Negative Pressure

    Pat The roof purlins and insulated cladding we are generally expected to specify is roughly around half the load of the wind uplift load. I can't even think of something practical that a light weight roof could be weighted down with. Ballast wouldn't be an option on this roof due to the fact...
  6. FinnB

    Bow String Roof Truss - Wind Uplift Net Negative Pressure

    Here's a lattice truss option attached. Top and bottom chord 120x8mm (5x1/3") equal angle with the two middle members of the top chord slightly heavier. JLNJ.....I suppose the bottom chord could be prestressed to ensure it does not go into tension but it still has no compression capacity so I...
  7. FinnB

    Bow String Roof Truss - Wind Uplift Net Negative Pressure

    In terms of letting the bottom chord buckle leaving the top chord to fend for itself in a heavy wind is something I looked at. It doesn't work. For gravity loads using a steel 254x146x31UB i.e. a light 10"x6" I beam with a 36mm (1.4 inch)tie rod is very effiecient structurallly. In the uplift...
  8. FinnB

    Bow String Roof Truss - Wind Uplift Net Negative Pressure

    I have been looking at a roof truss for the past few hours and I would like to get a few opinions. The truss is a bow string arch which is popular for school halls where I work, Ireland. There are many example of trusses where I live that use only steel rods for the bottom chord. Some of the...
  9. FinnB

    What Does Stamping Drawings "Reviewed With Comments" Mean to You?

    Lion06......In the scenario I described, the roof lifting off in the wind, the consulting engineer (or EOR in the US) had checked the subcontractor design and drawings. The problem was the check he carried out was only to ensure the contrator design was in general conformance with the design...
  10. FinnB

    What Does Stamping Drawings "Reviewed With Comments" Mean to You?

    dik........thanks for your response. It is similar to what we have in our specification. What you have there explicitly spells out very clearly the contractors responsibility. There are some good notes in it that I may add to our spec. I had a conversation today with a very senior engineer...
  11. FinnB

    What Does Stamping Drawings "Reviewed With Comments" Mean to You?

    Hi Brad, I'm learning a lot about how some PEMB's suppliers operate! They are very much suiting themselves on this job. Unfortunately the client sees it that the PEMB supplier and the engineer should get the building right and as such are not that concerned about excuses for errors. Their...
  12. FinnB

    What Does Stamping Drawings "Reviewed With Comments" Mean to You?

    Thanks for the reference JAE. I had a brief look throught the document and the clause below covers drawing approvals. It would seem to me from reading this that the checking engineer is taking responsiblity for everything on the the fabricators drawings except for cutting dimensions and...
  13. FinnB

    What Does Stamping Drawings "Reviewed With Comments" Mean to You?

    Thanks for the replies guys. It seems to me that what "Reviewed/Approved with Comments" / "General Conformance Review" actually means is open to some interpretation and is a bit of a grey area. I would say that what goes for common practice in the industry in respect to responsibility for...
  14. FinnB

    What Does Stamping Drawings "Reviewed With Comments" Mean to You?

    OHIOMatt/ToadJones On the project I am working on there is no Architect as the buildings are fairly basic sheds. The buildings range up to 300ft in length with 100ft span portal frames. We the engineers set out the building dimensionally so an architect was not deemed to be required. Do I...
  15. FinnB

    What Does Stamping Drawings "Reviewed With Comments" Mean to You?

    ToadJones - the drawings I am referring are steel fabrication shop drawimgs. What does it mean in you office when you stamp drawimgs "Reviewed with Comments"?

Part and Inventory Search