Sorry, I see you did provide some data in the original post.
The H.Y. Fang plot is the most correct based on the lateral loading being 2X the calculated load as noted in the Fang text. The other plot is incorrect and not representative of the point loading and Boussinesq distribution.
There is...
Please provide the example you are modeling. What is Q load and and Q offset distance from the wall that is represented by the curves. If you are using Poisson's ratio, what is the value? Most simplified equations assume 0.50 in the general Boussinesq so that the term (1 - 2u) goes to zero and...
The 2' of roadway surcharge for retaining walls comes from AASHTO whereas building codes and design guides typically use 250 psf. The 2' of soil surcharge would only be accurate if the load was from trucks carrying the backfill material, haha. Seriously, the weight of backfill varies from 100...
Rockery is a gravity wall system, FlexMSE is a MSE wall or reinforced steepened slope system. The excavation, backfill, and construction requirements are considerably different.
It would really have a lot to do with the height of the walls you are considering. I suspect that the "rocks" in a...
Hello fattdad,
We're heading back to the discussions about Bousinesseq, 2 X Bousinesseq, and trial wedge surcharge loads. There are lots of conflicting theory on the treatment of surcharges, how, when and where.
Bowles discusses this relative to Spangler's testing as I recall. AASHTO...
There are charts for estimating various friction angles of dissimilar materials (NAVFAC, AASHTO) as it is not practical to actually test for these. Using 1/2 - 2/3 of soil phi angle for a concrete wall interface is customary but then this would not apply to a Rankine form of earth pressure...
(also not intended to derail the conversation that appears to have stopped)
fattdad - 50 states and probably about that many different approaches. Sometimes it is a funding issue when money becomes available and a project is pushed forward on a D-B basis ahead of the engineering thus minimal...
fattdad - Your observation is consistent with the DOT market. However, there are some DOT's and and many transit agencies that attempt to push all soil stability responsibility onto the wall designer via the contract specifications which is why all bid documents have to be reviewed. I have been...
ps: As a side issue, the NCMA Design Manual 3rd edition "attempts" to define responsibilities of the parties in a construction project (generally private sector projects). While this is good in concept, the plans and specification of a project govern responsibilities as well as legal precedence...
In the US, the majority of MSE walls with panels and steel reinforcement are for state and federal transportation departments who determine what kinds of retaining walls are required at a location prior to bidding based on geotechnical, structural, aesthetic, and cost requirements. In most...
From a quick internet search:
http://aashtoresource.org/docs/default-source/newsletter/three-musketeers-in-soils-testing-atterberg-casagrande-and-terzaghi---printer-friendly.pdf?sfvrsn=0
Seems to be a nice summary of the "beginning" and I am sure there are many like it.
The crane is usually a couple of isolated point or strip loads of finite length so modeling as continuous line or strip load in a conventional slope stability program would tend to be overly conservative. A 3D slope stability modeling would probably be more appropriate for a crane on surface...
