Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations cowski on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Recent content by CarlB

  1. CarlB

    Equations for Strip Surcharge Loading Inconsistencies

    There have been many Eng-Tips discussions on strip surcharge lateral pressures, you can find in a search. The one EireChch mentions is a good one: https://www.eng-tips.com/threads/lateral-earth-pressure-from-surcharges-and-the-2x-factor.330567 It seems apparent the Das formula is in error, all...
  2. CarlB

    minimum cover for schedule 80 pvc

    Per manufacturer guides, 1 foot cover probably works. https://www.jmeagle.com/sites/default/files/TB06DepthofBurialforPVC.pdf https://www.jmeagle.com/sites/default/files/TB05PVCSewerBurialDepth.pdf
  3. CarlB

    Calculating Sliding Resistance for Equipment Foundation Partially Supported by Soil

    The contact area is not a factor in sliding resistance, the resistance=weight x coefficient of friction. As you recognized, all the weight is transferred to the walls, the void has no 'bearing' on the analysis. There may be a small portion of the slab weight supported on the soil, but as...
  4. CarlB

    Radiant Heated Floor Slab

    Are 2 layers of reinforcing necessary? Aircraft pavement is typically thicker, and unreinforced (or at least used to be). The steel was not necessary for support/structural reasons. Use of appropriate contraction joints addressed crack control.
  5. CarlB

    Question about using hidden linetypes

    You could show it either way, as long as it's well identified which is which. I'd think the road below is more pertinent to the utility installation, so would show the bridge above with less dominant linework, either hidden/dashed, or faded.
  6. CarlB

    Reactions of flat plate pinned on 3 sides

    The load case from "Moments and Reactions for Rectangular Plates" is not quite hinged 3 sides, but may give close results for reactions.
  7. CarlB

    Frost heave in saturated gravel below foundation

    If you think the groundwater can be controlled sufficiently to perform earthwork to that depth, why not instead just place the pier below the frost level and forego the subgrade replacement with gravel? The gravel replacement idea should provide adequate foundation support, as the chance of...
  8. CarlB

    Grading Tolerances

    You mentioned 'tolerances', what are they, what is required by the specifications? For a finished surface of earth (vs pavement), a typical tolerance (allowed deviation from design grade) is something on the order of +/- 0.05 feet, or about 1/2 inch. The tolerance would be independent of slope...
  9. CarlB

    Project Geotechnical Report

    That soil type (silty sand), very low blow counts, below the water table, present very high chance of liquefication during a seismic event, leading to settlement, sand boils, etc. Unless site is in a very low seismic region.
  10. CarlB

    Grenoble method for pile uplift verifications

    The following paper appears to have a worked example using the Grenoble method...
  11. CarlB

    AutoCAD: How do I stop OSnap defaults from overriding @(relative x, y) coordinates?

    Not all system variables can be set through user accessed settings, but this one can be apparently (I read online, didn’t verify): Tools/Options/User Preferences/Prioroty for Coordinate Data Entry ... select "Keyboard Entry" vs "Running Object Snap".
  12. CarlB

    AutoCAD: How do I stop OSnap defaults from overriding @(relative x, y) coordinates?

    Set OSNAPCOORD to 1 or 2 to prevent osnaps from controlling during coordinate entries https://help.autodesk.com/view/ACD/2025/ENU/?guid=GUID-94994960-5E62-4044-BEF7-9CF91667F641
  13. CarlB

    Floor drain flow rates

    I would think the PC design/sizing is more a function of the maximum expected inflow rate, rather than daily flow rate. The PC size is as necessary to limit number of pump starts per hour. So maybe you should be asking the ME, and possibly the bakery, what is the maximum expected flowrate &...
  14. CarlB

    Foundation Design Consultations - Need Guidance

    Regarding #2: I'm guessing by "shear", this is lateral load from the structure that will transfer to the foundation. But depending on how the load is transferred, some may be resisted by grade beams (setting on the earth) and grade slabs. It some cases it may be reasonable to assume that those...
  15. CarlB

    Interior Face Frost Protection Depth for Unheated Space

    Your scheme leaves some cold bridges from the inside cold temperatures, to the footing. The below additional insulation could address that. Though the slab itself could experience frost effects.

Part and Inventory Search