Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations cowski on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Recent content by BiPolarMoment

  1. BiPolarMoment

    Sharpness/Dullness Evaluation/Testing of non-standard cutting geometry

    No surface treatments. Cutting articular cartilage, cortical and cancellous bone. I'm still not convinced how often we are seeing dullness that was induced by direct cutting of the tissues, but that doesn't completely obviate the need to assess the sharpness if only to say that we do/can as...
  2. BiPolarMoment

    Sharpness/Dullness Evaluation/Testing of non-standard cutting geometry

    CCW as illustrated in the picture, yes. Torque/load to cut may be an option if we can identify a suitable medium that doesn't in itself cause undue abrasion. Will have to kick that around. One thing I intentionally didn't mention since it's related but presently out-of-scope, is that the alloy...
  3. BiPolarMoment

    Sharpness/Dullness Evaluation/Testing of non-standard cutting geometry

    Well, that's a tease--it shows up in the post preview before submitting. I tried it a little different way:
  4. BiPolarMoment

    Sharpness/Dullness Evaluation/Testing of non-standard cutting geometry

    We have some custom stainless steel tools with hole saw type geometry where the cutting 'tips' are not of a standard geometry--it has a scalloped leading edge which creates two sharp 'peaks' at the innermost and outermost edges: These items are intended for limited re-use, but we would like...
  5. BiPolarMoment

    Magnetic 316L and galling (investigation)

    Regulatory agencies/bodies that see "FDA recognized consensus standard" and stop asking additional questions? 😅
  6. BiPolarMoment

    Magnetic 316L and galling (investigation)

    Thanks for the suggestion, although this might be harder to 'sell' since some may ask "is that [surgical] stainless steel?" -- if we can say "Yes, it meets chemical requirements of ASTM F899" then great, but...:confused:
  7. BiPolarMoment

    Magnetic 316L and galling (investigation)

    All materials in this equation are nominally 316L; the form of the actual raw materials is not specified on the drawings, however, according to the material certs, the 'new' (non-magnetic) plate was made from 1.5" smooth turned cold-finished round bar; the 'new' mating post appears to be made...
  8. BiPolarMoment

    Magnetic 316L and galling (investigation)

    So, we have some machined parts of somewhat dubious history where the drawings indicate the parts are 316L but due to the fact one of the components exhibited ferromagnetism and was not galling in a same-material pair, we suspected the material may actually be hardened 400 series (e.g. 416/420)...
  9. BiPolarMoment

    Removing smut and passivating a 304 welded part

    This is amazing; before I go buy a bottle to experiment with, what is the visible reaction that I should expect in such a case? [thumbsup2]
  10. BiPolarMoment

    Hello! Can you please help me id

    I have done that as well, but not ideal. [sadeyes]
  11. BiPolarMoment

    Hello! Can you please help me id

    The reason is so people like me, when opening a drawing for the first time and having no idea of the revision history... are left to wonder if there is something important associated to that bubble with a letter in it. On an associated note: unless it has improved in the last few...
  12. BiPolarMoment

    The cheapest methods to make this FPV Drone frame parts that are made from super stiff carbon?

    Nothing to add other than these pieces are almost certainly molded, possibly CFRP.
  13. BiPolarMoment

    Measuring line profile and basic dimensions

    Since you are already relying on CAD model, just omit any 'points' along the path and force them to choose. If they ask which points they need to measure to know if the part is acceptable, then fire them. "Which dimensions are critical to meet specification? [ponder]" "All of them" [flame]
  14. BiPolarMoment

    ISO drafting standard - Thread annotation with depth

    I lean towards the "useful" in the sense that it beats into the [idiot] reader's head that partial threads don't do me any good but you are fine to have as many as you'd like past where there are full threads. Generally, though, I find I'd care to use a note like that where I know the hole depth...

Part and Inventory Search